The product: Betty Crocker Salted Caramel and Eggnog Cookie Mixes What we thought: With little bits of visible caramel poking through, the salted caramel cookies had us at hello. Sweet and chewy, they were just as delicious as expected while being small enough to not feel like a giant overindulgence. We were also pleasantly surprised with the eggnog cookies. They turned out a little thicker than the salted caramel cookies, but we thought they were spiced to perfection. And because, ‘tis the season, we added a little Betty Crocker Buttercream Frosting plus red and green sprinkles to make them even more festive. Goes perfectly with: A hot cup of cocoa.