Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of molasses do you use for molasses cookies?
There are several kinds of molasses on the grocery store shelf, but which one is best for molasses cookies? Choices include light, cooking, unsulphured, and blackstrap. Each style is a by-product of the sugar-making process, and they lend different flavors to baked goods. If you’d like a cookie with a lighter, sweeter flavor, cooking molasses is a good choice. Go with blackstrap molasses for a more robust flavor. If you’re not sure, unsulphured molasses is a great all-purpose choice.
Can I use butter instead of shortening in my molasses cookies?
While both would technically work, there are reasons for using shortening versus butter when mixing certain types of cookie dough. Shortening has a higher melting point, so cookies will hold their shape longer in the oven before the fat melts in the dough (and shortening doesn’t release any steam like butter) resulting in moist, chewy cookies–the ideal texture for soft molasses cookies. Butter melts more quickly and releases some steam so the cookies would be crisper and spread more, and have a distinctly buttery flavor. Some recipes even use a combination of the two fats.
(function() {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
var componentMetadata = JSON.parse('\x7b\x22componentName\x22\x3a\x22RecipeFAQ_2ee1ece6-a33c-4f37-aafb-6377bfa48ff1\x22,\x22deferOptions\x22\x3a\x7b\x22deferComponent\x22\x3afalse,\x22deferType\x22\x3a\x22None\x22,\x22deferId\x22\x3a\x22r92434ae8af5043939b66f8d70a0bb8e3\x22,\x22deferredContainerId\x22\x3a\x22\x2fmain\x2frdpFAQ\x22,\x22deferredContainerView\x22\x3anull\x7d,\x22viewName\x22\x3a\x22RecipeFAQ\x22\x7d');
var configuration = {"title":"Soft Molasses Cookies","introduction":"Mmm…molasses. These perfect, pillowy soft molasses cookies might even be better than the ones Grandma used to make. (But don’t worry, we won’t tell!) Betty has taken that classic spiced cookie recipe—with ginger, cinnamon and cloves—and positively perfected it to make the best ginger molasses cookies you’ve ever tasted. They’re baked with a soft, chewy center and a slightly crispy crunch on the outside, then dipped in sugar to give them a sweet finish. Whip up a batch during the holidays or whenever you’re craving cozy spiced cookies.","servingSize":"1 Cookie","image":{"small":{"media":"(min-width: 0px)","src":"https://mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ZHTgdgOUKkysPDZefOb8Sg_webp_base.webp?v=335f91c0\u0026t=e724eca7b3c24a8aaa6e089ed9e611fd"},"medium":{"media":"(min-width: 500px)","src":"https://mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ZHTgdgOUKkysPDZefOb8Sg_webp_base.webp?v=335f91c0\u0026t=191ddcab8d1c415fa10fa00a14351227"},"large":{"media":"(min-width: 767px)","src":"https://mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ZHTgdgOUKkysPDZefOb8Sg_webp_base.webp?v=335f91c0\u0026t=191ddcab8d1c415fa10fa00a14351227"},"alt":"Soft Molasses Cookies"},"contributor":{"label":"By","name":"Betty Crocker Kitchens","profileUrl":"/about-us","displayDate":{"label":"Updated","date":"May 19, 2026"}},"ingredientGroups":[{"ingredients":[{"quantity":"1","description":"cup packed brown sugar"},{"quantity":"1/2","description":"cup shortening"},{"quantity":"1/4","description":"cup butter, softened"},{"quantity":"1/4","description":"cup molasses"},{"quantity":"1","description":"egg"},{"quantity":"2 1/4","description":"cups Gold Medal™ All Purpose Flour"},{"quantity":"2","description":"teaspoons baking soda"},{"quantity":"1","description":"teaspoon ground cinnamon"},{"quantity":"1","description":"teaspoon ground ginger"},{"quantity":"1/2","description":"teaspoon ground cloves"},{"quantity":"1/4","description":"teaspoon salt"},{"quantity":"2","description":"tablespoons granulated sugar"}]}],"steps":[{"description":"\u003cp\u003eHeat oven to 325°F. In large bowl, beat brown sugar, shortening, butter, molasses, and egg with electric mixer on medium speed, or mix with spoon. Stir in remaining ingredients except granulated sugar.\u003c/p\u003e","stepShotImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/SQQr4Jpyj0WgH9lzbdZCWQ_webp_base.webp?v=f0ecda08\u0026t=51a43a57af4046789e5a7f20567b1195"},{"description":"\u003cp\u003eShape dough into 1 1/2-inch balls. Dip tops into granulated sugar. On ungreased large cookie sheet, place balls, sugared sides up, about 2 inches apart.\u003c/p\u003e","stepShotImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/hAgWJzAu-0KPGWP01TzvPg_webp_base.webp?v=fa3c1eae\u0026t=51a43a57af4046789e5a7f20567b1195"},{"description":"\u003cp\u003eBake 11 to 13 minutes or just until edges are set; centers will be soft. Cool 3 minutes on cookie sheet. Remove from cookie sheet to cooling rack. Cool completely, about 30 minutes.\u003c/p\u003e","stepShotImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/qJ38y1sCZUimG8KyE5xXpA_webp_base.webp?v=7f968c90\u0026t=51a43a57af4046789e5a7f20567b1195"}],"tips":[{"title":"","description":"Searching for the perfect soft molasses cookie? Look no further than this classic recipe. Bake up a batch and see for yourself! ","category":"Rich Snippet","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"When shopping for your ingredients, choose shortening in easy-to-measure sticks. It eliminates messy measuring in cups.","category":"Recipe/Ingredient Facts","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eThere is enough fat in these tender cookies that they won’t stick to the baking sheets. But for easier cleanup, line the baking sheets with baking parchment paper. The parchment can be used several times before composting or recycling it.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Recipe/Ingredient Facts","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eThe key to successful baking is measuring accurately. Use a spoon to scoop the flour into the measuring cup, then level off the top with a flat-edged utensil, such as a knife.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Techniques","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"For easy cleanup, spray the inside of the measuring cup with cooking spray first so the molasses will slide out of the cup easily.","category":"Techniques","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"The classics are classics for a reason–and this tasty, traditional treat proves that tenfold. With a spicy, sweet flavor that reminds you of happy holidays and time spent in the kitchen with loved ones, these soft molasses cookies are a little bite of nostalgia. Make a batch today to enjoy and share!","category":"Editorial","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"Recipe meets Kitchen Tested criteria. Reviewed as part of project MSO-5941 BC Audit 200 recipes","category":"Kitchen Tested","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eKitchen Tested: 5/2026\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Kitchen Tested","tipShots":[]}],"kitchenTips":[{"title":"","description":"When shopping for your ingredients, choose shortening in easy-to-measure sticks. It eliminates messy measuring in cups.","category":"Recipe/Ingredient Facts","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eThere is enough fat in these tender cookies that they won’t stick to the baking sheets. But for easier cleanup, line the baking sheets with baking parchment paper. The parchment can be used several times before composting or recycling it.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Recipe/Ingredient Facts","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eThe key to successful baking is measuring accurately. Use a spoon to scoop the flour into the measuring cup, then level off the top with a flat-edged utensil, such as a knife.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Techniques","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"For easy cleanup, spray the inside of the measuring cup with cooking spray first so the molasses will slide out of the cup easily.","category":"Techniques","tipShots":[]}],"additionalContent":[{"title":"What are molasses cookies?","description":"\u003cp\u003eA true classic, molasses cookies have been around since the late 1800s. At the time, molasses was widely used in cookies because it was much less expensive than white sugar. After WWI, the price of white sugar fell and cookies and other baked goods were once again more commonly made with refined sugar. Today, molasses cookies are loved for their sweet and lightly spiced flavor with notes of ginger, cinnamon, and cloves. This nostalgic sweet is popular around the holidays but is absolutely delightful in any season.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"SEO Content_1","tipShots":[]},{"title":"How do you make molasses cookies?","description":"\u003cp\u003eFor this simple recipe, combine shortening and butter with brown sugar, molasses, and egg. Then, add the dry ingredients, including flour, baking soda, and that quintessential blend of spices. Dipping your dough in granulated sugar before baking gives your cookies that sparkly, crackly top everyone loves. And while your cookies are baking, your house will smell absolutely amazing. Is your mouth watering yet?\u003c/p\u003e","category":"SEO Content_2","tipShots":[]}],"faq":[{"title":"What kind of molasses do you use for molasses cookies?","description":"\u003cp\u003eThere are several kinds of molasses on the grocery store shelf, but which one is best for molasses cookies? Choices include light, cooking, unsulphured, and blackstrap. Each style is a by-product of the sugar-making process, and they lend different flavors to baked goods. If you’d like a cookie with a lighter, sweeter flavor, cooking molasses is a good choice. Go with blackstrap molasses for a more robust flavor. If you’re not sure, unsulphured molasses is a great all-purpose choice.\u003c/p\u003e","category":"FAQ_1","tipShots":[]},{"title":"Can I use butter instead of shortening in my molasses cookies?","description":"While both would technically work, there are reasons for using shortening versus butter when mixing certain types of cookie dough. Shortening has a higher melting point, so cookies will hold their shape longer in the oven before the fat melts in the dough (and shortening doesn’t release any steam like butter) resulting in moist, chewy cookies–the ideal texture for soft molasses cookies. Butter melts more quickly and releases some steam so the cookies would be crisper and spread more, and have a distinctly buttery flavor. Some recipes even use a combination of the two fats. ","category":"FAQ_3","tipShots":[]}],"tipCategories":[{"categoryName":"Editorial","heading":"More About This Recipe","cssClass":"recipePartStory","expandOnInit":false,"expandText":"More +","collapseText":"Less -","expandEventName":"","collapseEventName":"","image":"","tips":[{"title":"","description":"The classics are classics for a reason–and this tasty, traditional treat proves that tenfold. With a spicy, sweet flavor that reminds you of happy holidays and time spent in the kitchen with loved ones, these soft molasses cookies are a little bite of nostalgia. Make a batch today to enjoy and share!","category":"Editorial","tipShots":[]}],"isExpandable":false},{"categoryName":"Kitchen Tested","heading":"More About This Recipe","cssClass":"recipePartStory","expandOnInit":false,"expandText":"More +","collapseText":"Less -","expandEventName":"","collapseEventName":"","image":"","tips":[{"title":"","description":"Recipe meets Kitchen Tested criteria. Reviewed as part of project MSO-5941 BC Audit 200 recipes","category":"Kitchen Tested","tipShots":[]},{"title":"","description":"\u003cp\u003eKitchen Tested: 5/2026\u003c/p\u003e","category":"Kitchen Tested","tipShots":[]}],"isExpandable":false},{"categoryName":"Rich Snippet","heading":"","cssClass":"recipePartMethodNote","expandOnInit":false,"expandText":"More +","collapseText":"Less -","expandEventName":"","collapseEventName":"","image":"","tips":[{"title":"","description":"Searching for the perfect soft molasses cookie? Look no further than this classic recipe. Bake up a batch and see for yourself! ","category":"Rich Snippet","tipShots":[]}],"isExpandable":false}],"nutritionInfo":{"configuration":{"showAsTable":false,"noNutritionInformationAvailableMessage":"Nutrition Facts are not available for this recipe","poweredByText":"\u003cp\u003eNutrition information for this recipe is estimated using a leading nutrition calculation application, but is an estimate only. Actual nutrition values will vary based on the exact ingredients or brands you may use.\u003c/p\u003e\n\u003ca href=\u0022http://developer.edamam.com\u0022\u003ePowered By \u003cimg src=\u0022-/media/05422024943D4056883B09BBC2576F20.ashx\u0022 alt=\u0022Edamam\u0022 /\u003e\u003c/a\u003e","nutritionChartTitle":"Nutrition Facts","nutritionInformationLabel":"Nutrition","servingSizeText":"Serving Size:","dailyValuesDisclaimer":"*Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.","percentDailyValueText":"% Daily Value","percentDailyValueFooterTitleText":"% Daily Value*:","exchangeInformationTitleText":"Exchanges:","nutritionFactsExpandText":"More Nutrition","nutritionFactsCollapseText":"Less Nutrition"},"servingSize":"1 Cookie","exchangeInfo":"Free","showPoweredBy":false,"showRecipeTotalTime":true,"showRecipePrepTime":true,"showCarbohydrateChoices":false},"trademarks":[],"labels":{"ingredientsHeader":"Ingredients","stepsHeader":"Instructions","stepsImageHideText":"Hide Images","stepsImageShowText":"Show Images","stepNumberText":"Step","faqHeader":"Frequently Asked Questions","tipsHeader":"Recipe Tips","tipItemHeadingFormat":"tip {0}","postedBy":"By","copyright":"© {yyyy} ®/TM General Mills All Rights Reserved","showDrawerText":"Show ","hideDrawerText":"Hide","expandDescriptionText":"More +","collapseDescriptionText":"Less -","ariaLiveLabelFormat":"Showing {0} through {1} of {2}","scrollLeftButtonLabel":"Scroll Left","scrollRightButtonLabel":"Scroll Right","includeScrollIndicator":true},"primaryAttributes":[{"label":"Prep Time","values":[{"text":"15","label":"min"}]},{"label":"Total","values":[{"text":"1","label":"hr"},{"text":"15","label":"min"}]},{"label":"Servings","values":[{"text":"24"}]},{"label":"Ingredients","values":[{"text":"12"}]}],"secondaryAttributes":[],"badges":[{"badgeType":3,"badgeText":"","label":"kitchen tested","imageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/BC/Images/Shared/RecipeParts/KitchenTested_BC1_new.jpg?sc_lang=en","linkUrl":"/about-us/kitchen-tested","metaDataTags":[],"showMemberInfo":false,"matchedMetadataId":"00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000"},{"badgeType":2,"badgeText":"Gold Medal Flour","label":"Make With","imageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/BC/Images/Shared/RecipeParts/make-with/Package_GoldMedalv3.png?sc_lang=en","metaDataTags":["9223a3ed-9c14-580f-b9e7-f31f0ba02c9e"],"showMemberInfo":false,"matchedMetadataId":"9223a3ed-9c14-580f-b9e7-f31f0ba02c9e"}],"backgroundImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/BC/Images/Shared/RecipeParts/img-bc-rdp-heroDotPattern.png?sc_lang=en","breadcrumbs":{"links":[{"url":"/","label":"Home"},{"url":"/recipes","label":"Recipes"},{"url":"/recipes/dishes/cookie-recipes/shaped-and-molded-cookies","label":"Shaped \u0026 Molded Cookies"}],"currentPageName":"Soft Molasses Cookies"}};
var moduleName = 'recipeFaq';
var isVueModule = true;
GeneralMills.PandoSites.RegisterControlInstance(moduleName, configuration, componentMetadata, isVueModule)
});
})();