• Save
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Print

How to Build the Perfect Cookie Tray

Created October 25, 2019
Give your cookie tray extra love by adding a little bit of everything to the mix!
How do you build the perfect cookie tray? With variety! Having a variety of cookie types is the key to crafting a sublime cookie tray. It may seem like a lot but having next to nine different options will ensure that there’s something for all your party-goers to enjoy. From Classic Christmas Sugar Cookie Cutouts to Buckeye Fudge, this guide to building the perfect cookie tray is foolproof!

  1. No cookie tray is complete without Classic Christmas Sugar Cookie Cutouts.
  2. Sweet and salty is always a crowd-pleaser, and especially delicious in our Salted Butterscotch Pudding Pretzel Cookies.
  3. Add a little variety with our Buckeye Fudge.
  4. Indulge in the true flavors of Christmas with our Molasses Chewies.
  5. Light and airy, Russian Tea Cakes are the timeless classic that belongs on every cookie tray.
  6. Cinnamon, sugar and brown butter create the perfect snickerdoodles! Make sure these Easy Browned Butter Snickerdoodles are part of your Christmas cookie exchange!
  7. Don’t be surprised when these Oreo™-Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie Bombs are the first treats to disappear from you cookie tray.
  8. Cream Cheese Sugar Cookies are the tender, from-scratch cookie that will please kids of all ages.
  9. Cut through the cookie clutter with our beloved Easy Ritz™Toffee recipe! Crunchy, sweet and salty, this is the perfect treat to round out your cookie tray.

Want even more cookie inspiration? Check out the Christmas Cookies We Always Make From Scratch.