Skip to Content
  • Save
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Print

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cones

By Deborah Harroun
Created January 10, 2017
Forget waiting for the ice cream truck – make your own ice cream cone treats at home!

I grew up on a remote street outside the city limits, so ice cream trucks were not a common occurrence. In fact, I can only remember a handful of times throughout my childhood when the ice cream truck would make it out to my neighborhood. The minute I heard that distinct music, I would scramble inside and dig through everything I could think of to find loose change. Then I’d back outside to meet the truck and buy myself a frozen treat. 

These days, it seems even rarer to see an ice cream truck slowly driving through the streets. But guess what? It doesn’t matter, because you can make your own ice cream treats. (And don’t tell the ice cream man, but I think that these taste even better!) Here’s how you make them. You will need chocolate chips, peanut butter, chopped peanuts, peanut butter cup ice cream and sugar cones.


The easiest way to assemble these–and to keep them standing–is to put each of the cones into a cup or a glass.


Melt 4 tablespoons of the chocolate in a food-safe, resealable plastic bag; squirt the chocolate into the bottom of the cones. This stops any ice cream from leaking out of the bottom of the cone. (Plus, it’s my favorite part to eat!)


Fill each of the cones with ice cream.


Add a scoop of ice cream to the top of each cone. Place the cones in the cups into the freezer; freeze until the ice cream is completely firm.


Combine the rest of the chocolate chips and the peanut butter; melt in the microwave. Let the chocolate mixture sit until it is still liquid but almost cool to the touch.


Take the cones from the freezer and immediately dip into the melted chocolate mixture. Roll in the chopped peanuts. Return the cones to the cups; freeze completely


I’ll scream, you’ll scream, everyone will scream for this ice cream!