Skip to Content
  • Save
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Print

Roast Turkey Dinner Cake

By Heather Baird
Created January 10, 2017
Thanksgiving guests will do a double-take when turkey is served twice!

Turkey and dressing, mashed potatoes with gravy and peas… doesn’t sound much like dessert, does it? But it is! This adorable cake looks just like a roast turkey, and it comes complete with cupcake side dishes. It’s just the thing to lighten the mood around the holiday table, and it would make the funniest birthday cake for those celebrating in November. Here’s how to make it!

Step 1:

To get started, you’ll need a 2-quart stainless steel bowl in which to bake the cake. It needs to be greased and floured well to prevent sticking. (I suggest using a flour-based cooking spray, if you have it.)

Turkey Dinner Cake 1

Step 2:

For the batter, place the cake mix and 2 tablespoons ground cinnamon in a large bowl.

Turkey Dinner Cake 2

Step 3:

Whisk together until the cinnamon is evenly dispersed.

Turkey Dinner Cake 3

Step 4:

Add eggs, oil and water as directed on the cake mix box and mix with a hand mixer on low speed. Pour batter into the prepared bowl.

Turkey Dinner Cake 4

Step 5:

Bake cake for about 55 minutes and then turn out onto a serving plate. Refrigerate for about two hours.

Turkey Dinner Cake 5

Step 6:

While you wait for the cake to chill, prepare the cupcakes. Line two cupcake tins with papers.

Turkey Dinner Cake 6

Step 7:

Prepare batter as before with the bowl cake using the remaining box of cake mix and ground cinnamon. Fill cupcake papers ¾-full.

Turkey Dinner Cake 7

Step 8:

Bake for 18-20 minutes or until cakes spring back. Let cool completely.

Turkey Dinner Cake 8

Step 9:

When the round cake is thoroughly chilled, carve away two thick rounded edges leaving a turkey breast-shaped center. Reserve the two side pieces for later use.

Turkey Dinner Cake 9

Step 10:

Cut an inward notch away from one tapered end, creating the neck area.

Turkey Dinner Cake 10

Step 11:

Cut another notch slightly larger inward notch at the opposite end. Refrigerate while you carve the drumsticks.

Turkey Dinner Cake 11

Step 12:

Use the reserved cake pieces to carve two drumsticks.

Turkey Dinner Cake 12

Step 13:

This doesn’t have to be perfect, just do the best you can! (The rest will be perfected with frosting!)

Turkey Dinner Cake 13

Step 14:

To make the frosting, add cocoa powder a little at a time until a light brown color is achieved.

Turkey Dinner Cake 14

Step 15:

Frost the cake and drumstick pieces with a thin coat of icing and refrigerate for 30 minutes.

Turkey Dinner Cake 15

Step 16:

Lay drumstick pieces on either side of the cake and cover with a final coat of frosting.

Turkey Dinner Cake 16

Step 17:

Turkey frills (the drumstick decorations) can be made from a piece of plain copy paper. Cut an 8 1/2 by 11 sheet of white paper in half and then fold each of those pieces in half.

Turkey Dinner Cake 17

Step 18:

Hold both pieces of folded paper together and cut equally spaced fringe at the folded edge with scissors. Leave about 1/2-inch of uncut space at the top edge. Open each fringed paper and fold the opposite direction.

Turkey Dinner Cake 18

Step 19:

Wrap paper around two fingers and fasten with a piece of cellophane tape. Place a frill on the end of each drumstick just before serving.

Turkey Dinner Cake 19

Step 20:

Cut 3 or 4 cupcakes into cubes to make the turkey “stuffing.”

Turkey Dinner Cake 20

Step 21:

Place the cake cubes around the bottom of the cake between the turkey drumsticks. You may also use these pieces to slightly prop ends of the turkey legs upward.

Turkey Dinner Cake 21

Step 22:

To make the “peas” cupcakes, cover 10 cupcakes in 1-2 tablespoons of frosting.

Turkey Dinner Cake 22

Step 23:

Dip the frosted cupcake tops in the green candies.

Turkey Dinner Cake 23

Step 24:

For the “mashed potatoes” cupcakes, use a thick covering of frosting and use a spoon to create a divot in the top. Pour maple syrup into the divot.

Turkey Dinner Cake 24

Step 25:

Add a yellow fruit chew “butter pat” in the center of the divot.

Turkey Dinner Cake 25

Step 26:

Serve cupcakes alongside the roast turkey cake.

PIN_Turkey Dinner Cake