Reviews & Comments

This is a great recipe. It is a basic recipe that allows extras to be added if so desired. I made it a while back with adding 1 can water chestnuts, sliced,then I juliened them and ,added 8 thinly sliced radishes that I juliened. I added 1/2 cup diced sweet red pepper and 1/2 cup diced green pepper,1/2 cup diced celery,added 1/2 teaspoon celery seeds,4 sliced green onions, 1/3 cup "FINELY" chopped WHITE ONION,1/2 teaspoon dried dill along with 2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh dill,1/2 cup diced homemade dill pickles,8 hard boiled eggs chopped.dressing-- mayonaise, sour cream,dill pickle juice,1 tablespoon sugar 1 tablespoon rice wine vinegar,yellow mustard,salt and fresh ground pepper to taste. Some times I add 2 cans drained ,MEDIUM SHRIMP, at the very last,then carefuly FOLD them into the potaoe mixture.You can then add a fresh squeeze of lemon juice.Top with HUNGARIAN PAPRIKA,tomatoe rosettes and small fresh celery leaves

This is awesome potato salad but 10 minutes hands on prep is a joke...I allow a good hour of steady work to make this dish, including washing pots, pans, cutting boards, knives, measuring spoons, bowls, peeling eggs, washing celery, chopping sweet pickles (the recipe could use a few)--it takes 10 minutes to just peel and chop the potatos after cooking. In any case, it is worth it, classic and delicious and someone always asks for the recipe.

I thought this potato salad was super easy and so yummy. If you use vinegar in yur recipe I would advise against using salt, but I dont like things that are too salty. I also added sweet relish because I like things a little sweeter. I took the finished product to a barbeque and left with an empty bowl. :)

I made this Potato Salad in June and everyone loved it. My mother in law and my brother absolutly love this salad as it is on the recipe but for my mom I have to adjust the recipe a little. When I make this salad for my mom I take out the vinegar and hard boiled eggs and add some sugar, relish, pickle juice, and a little milk. Everybody has different taste when it comes to potato salad so I just have fun with it.