Reviews & Comments

Will not make again - pudding mix just sat on top of cake. Had to melt icing in mw and then poor on cake. Spreading icing would never have worked on top of pudding. What a waste of $. For a high rating, must give results instead of disappointment.

I found it difficult to spread the pudding and get it into the holes. I wonder if we poured the pudding as soon as it is mixed and not let it set up if it would work better. I will try that next time. I didn't like that the pudding and frosting mixed together. The cake was not pretty but it was moist and very tasty. I eliminated the candy on the top and felt it was minty enough. I had to use sugar free white chocolate pudding also since I couldn't find the regular. I would make it again and might even try different variations of extract, pudding and cake flavors.

Moist and delicious! I used choco pudding.

This cake is awesome! Very rich and chocolatey with a hint of mint! Delicious! Made it for my daughter's eighth birthday and we will definitely be making it again!

This is a very good cake. A lady I work with made it for a luncheon and everyone asked for the recipe. I made it for Christmas dinner. Everyone loved it! I did, however, find it extremely difficult to spread the frosting over the pudding. (Maybe I needed to poke more holes for the pudding to soak into.) The frosting and pudding got a bit mixed and the cake was not "pretty", but it sure tasted great and was a hit.