Chocolate Chip Heart Cookies I wanted so badly to have cute shaped cookies that i ignored the 5 bad reviews (out of 7). That was a mistake. I followed directions to the letter. And it went all downhill at the cookie cutter. The cookie dough was so sticky, it stuck to my fingers, to the cutter to the pan . . . The one cookie i got mostly shaped, spread out into misformed blob in the oven. On the bright side, they tasted good, and were moist and fluffy . . .