Fluffy Key Lime Pie Made it today for my family, we're from Miami so we're big fans of key lime pie. This is definitely a light recipe, we're used to a heavier pie but this was a great after dinner dessert that doesn't weigh you down. I would suggest using bottled key lime juice because I almost used the while pound bag of key limes just to get the 1/2 cup of juice. But it was very easy and very delicious!