ENDECA_EXCLUDE_START
Betty Crocker
Avatar
Get FREE Kitchen-Insider Access Now!
Sign Up / Log In or Learn More
ENDECA_EXCLUDE_END

Message Boards

Scratch Bakers' Club

Share the simple pleasure of time well spent in the kitchen. Talk to fellow scratch bakers about your latest baking experiences, favorite recipes, tips and techniques!

Pie Crusts

I am having trouble making from scratch a pie crust.  I use to make pie crusts but for the last 10 years I have bought crusts.  Now I am trying again to make them and I am using an old recipe from my Better Crocker Cookbook that I got when I was married in 1962. Has something changed?  My recipe calls for 1 cups flour, 1/2 tsp salt, 1/3 cup shortening, 2-3 T cold water.  When I made this today I did not even get to the water.  It was all ready too moist.  I went ahead and rolled it out but it was no good.  I tried to bake it with just cinnamon sugar on it and the crust was like sand.  It never did firm up.  I know it has to be too much shortening.  I used Crisco and I used Gold Medal flour so any body know what is happening?  


Bomar2


 

11/20/2009 1:45 PM
17 Replies to Pie Crusts

Some people report having problems with the new Crisco. It's been changed in the past couple of years to remove transfats. I've read that some people have said the best shortening to use for pie crusts is lard.

Those who forget the pasta are condemned to reheat it.
11/20/2009 6:43 PM

Just as I suspected.  I do not want to use lard.  I think I will experiment with the Crisco and try using less - maybe just a quarter of a cup.  I have a recipe to use oil but as I remember that didn't work as good either.  I will keep looking.  I could ask the Crisco people.  I think I will.  Thanks for replying.

11/21/2009 6:22 AM

Hi Bomar2


 I got my recipe from an old Better Homes and Garden cookbook which I still use til this day. I have never had a problem making pie crusts.


This is for a 2-crusted pie


4 cups flour


dash of salt


1 cup vegetable oil


10 Tablespoons of cold water


After measuring the oil into a measuring cup, I add the cold water then add it to the flour mixture. I let this set while making my filling. When the time comes to roll out, I put flour on the surface divide the pie dough in half. I also put some flour on the rolling pin. keep turning over and also adding a little more flour. Once I get the pie crust to the desired thickness and I take a knife and run it all around the edges of the pie crusts. Then take the pie crusts fold in half to put into the pie plate. I do the same with the other half.


To make a one crusted pie just cut the ingredients in half


grammasgirls

11/21/2009 7:22 AM

Bomar2, Check the crisco container to see if it says "whipped" or "creamed", if so, it may of had air whipped/creamed into it, which means your really getting less shortening. I usually mix shortening and yard 1/2 & 1/2. I also use unbrand shortening, you can buy it with animal fat in it which usually means lard. I'am not sure why it was to moist, already. I do know that some flour is dried then others. I also use ice water, not just water.The basic recipe you stated is correct, although I add 1T. more shortening. Lots of luck, Granna2

May you always have Christ in your Life,Family Close, Love to Share, Health to Spare, Food to eat,Family and Friends that Care! "IN GOD WE TRUST"
11/21/2009 10:12 AM

Goodmorning Bomar2


Here is my pie crust:


2 cups sifted flour


1 tsp salt


3/4 cup crisco shortening


1/4+ cup water, some times I have to add just a bit more.


I mix my crust with a fork just until it works together.  Don't over stir the dough.  I never use anything but crisco.


This makes one double pie crust


Enjoy, and please let me know how it turns out for you.


have a great day


Leila

11/21/2009 10:49 AM

One secret to making pie crust from scratch is to use ice cold water.


I will share my pie crust recipe I have used for years but will say the last time I made pie, my crust did not turn out so well and since I have read about the changing of the crisco, believe that could be why.  Anyway, this pie crust is a cannot mess up pie crust.


Pie Crust

 

4 cups flour

2 cups Crisco

1 Tablespoon Sugar

1 teaspoon salt

1/2 teaspoon baking powder

1 cup cold water

 (put water in refrigerator to have ice cold)

 

Mix first five ingredients with pastry cutter

( a pizza cutter will work)

Slowly add water.

Mix well until it forms a ball.

Refrigerate at least one hour.

Roll on floured board.

Makes 4 -  9 inch shells
11/21/2009 11:22 AM

I use a pie crust recipe that is never fail and very easy.


2c. flour


1 to2 t. salt


Measure Crico oil into a one cup measuring cup up to the 1/2 cup line - DO NOT POUR OUT.  Continue in same cup.  Pour milk into the oil and raise the measurement up to the 3/4 cup mark. Pour this milk, oil mixture into the flour and salt.


Stir with a fork.


Divide doughball into 2 equal pieces and roll out to desired size between wax paper.


Makes 2 crust for 9 inch pie.

11/21/2009 1:11 PM

Thank you very much for the tips.  I want to thank everyone for sharing their recipes.  I am going to make pie crusts this afternoon and I will let you know.  I am going to try the oil one first.  I have tried it before a long time ago and I think it was good.  I haven't ever put milk in it tho.  I am excited by all the suggestions.  I will be busy.  I remember that my mom always used really cold water and said that was the secret to good crust but this last crust was too wet before I put the water in.  I must have not followed the recipe correctly but it happened twice.  Well, thank you all.


Bomar2

11/25/2009 6:35 AM


This recipe made a successful flaky and light pie crust this Thanksgiving. I think the secret might have been that the cube of butter was fresh from the freezer and I chopped the frozen cube up and used it right away. This recipe is a combination of several other recipes.


Flaky Pie Crust


Makes single, 9-inch pie crust


Ingredients


1-1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1-1/2 teaspoons sugar
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 cup (8 Tbs, 1 cube) butter, almost frozen
2 tablespoons shortening, very cold (I used butter flavored Crisco)
3-1/2 tablespoons ice water (water with ice chips in it)


1. Mix flour, salt and sugar in food processor fitted with steel blade. Scatter almost frozen butter in 1/4 inch pieces over flour mixture. Cut butter into flour with about 5 or 10 2-second pulses. Add shortening and continue pulsing food processor in until flour is pale yellow and resembles coarse cornmeal with butter and shortening bits no larger than small peas, about five more 2-second pulses. Turn mixture into mixing bowl.


2. Sprinkle 3-tablespoons of ice water over mixture. With a fork, press down on dough and stir until dough sticks together, adding up to 1/2 tablespoon more ice water if dough will not come together. Shape dough into a ball with your hands. Flatten into 4-inch-wide
disk. Dust lightly with flour, wrap in plastic, and refrigerate for 60 minutes before rolling.


3. I rolled out the dough on a smooth pyrex glass cutting board with a standard wooden rolling pin. I tried a marble rolling pin, but is was just too heavy and hard to control. Use plenty of flour and also a steel spatula to slide under dough if it starts to stick. Roll the dough from the center out and rotate it a 1/4 turn after each pass of the rolling pin. I think the cold glass is better for the dough than a wood surface.


Those who forget the pasta are condemned to reheat it.
11/27/2009 10:21 PM

Antilope  Thanks I have been all over the internet looking for a pie crust recipe to use with a food processor as my


hands are so sore from the arthuritus I just can't make pie crust the other way, I knew I had seen a receipe using


a processor but couldn't find it, I am going to try doing it all in the processor and see how it works I know the one I


saw was all done this way so i'm going to give it a try tomorrow will let you know how it went  Thanks Again Trish42

Always Good Food PatriciaCushen
11/27/2009 11:56 PM

i have never tried making pie crust in a food processer, I think I'll try that with my recipe. Thanks, Granna2

May you always have Christ in your Life,Family Close, Love to Share, Health to Spare, Food to eat,Family and Friends that Care! "IN GOD WE TRUST"
11/28/2009 7:10 AM

I've seen people report that you should not use the food processor to mix in the water. That should be done by hand. I haven't tried mixing in the water with the food processor so I don't know how that would turn out.

Those who forget the pasta are condemned to reheat it.
11/28/2009 8:18 AM

bomar 2, my very favorite pie crust uses cream cheese and butter. it is absoutely delicious, flaky, foolproof. it is posted on my blog www.realbakingwithrose.com. put pie crust in the search box.


 


as for crisco, which i find totally lacking in flavor, it is necessary to use it cold or it will coat the flour making it impossible to absorb water and the piecrust will not hold together. i would cut the crisco into cubes about 3/4" in size and then freeze them before cutting them into the flour. you'll be amazed at the difference!

"Creativity is a bottomless well of inspiration."--Michael Batterberry, Publisher of Food Arts Magazine. Blissful Baking! Rose
12/2/2009 11:17 AM

Rose 


 


I am going to look up your recipe and try it.  I am also going to try the oil and milk recipe too.  I made my pie crust for Thanks and it turned out better.  I did use crisco and had it really cold.


Are the the Rose that wrote the Bread cook book.  I can't think of the name and I had to put it in storage because I made so much bread from it that I was getting to fat.  I loved that book and that way of making the starter with less yeast and letting it sit in the refrig overnight or for several hours.   Wonderful bread recipes!  I made lots of them.  In fact I may get it out and make some because my son has come to live with us and he loves bread.  I did not have good luck with the sour dough bread.  It wasn't  didn't rise up good but was ok.  I just need to practice more.  The egg bread was like dessert.  All that I made was great.  Good book.


Bomar

12/5/2009 4:30 PM

Bomar2:


Rose 


 


 


 


I am going to look up your recipe and try it.  I am also going to try the oil and milk recipe too.  I made my pie crust for Thanks and it turned out better.  I did use crisco and had it really cold.


 


Are the the Rose that wrote the Bread cook book.  I can't think of the name and I had to put it in storage because I made so much bread from it that I was getting to fat.  I loved that book and that way of making the starter with less yeast and letting it sit in the refrig overnight or for several hours.   Wonderful bread recipes!  I made lots of them.  In fact I may get it out and make some because my son has come to live with us and he loves bread.  I did not have good luck with the sour dough bread.  It wasn't  didn't rise up good but was ok.  I just need to practice more.  The egg bread was like dessert.  All that I made was great.  Good book.


 


Bomar


12/5/2009 5:01 PM

I don't know what I did but something didn't turn out like I wanted on the post before.  Anyway I have printed the pie recipe and have looked at it and it seems a little complicated for making the crust.  I don't have a food processor and it is going to take more time getting everything cold.  I am going to try it tho and will report in.  I just can't see myself baking it with a bag of beans on it.  In fact I didn't understand about pricking it.  I know about that if nothing is in the crust but I don't get the part about the sticky stuff.  Well, I am going to try it soon.  


Bomar

12/5/2009 5:05 PM

hi bomar! yes it's me! (author of the bread bible and 8 other books). so glad you like my bread recipes. the secret to sour dough is that the starter has to be fully active as if it doesn't double within 6 to 8 hours it won't raise the bread sufficiently. just keep feeding it after it does double as per the instructions and it will 'wake up' and perform as expected.

"Creativity is a bottomless well of inspiration."--Michael Batterberry, Publisher of Food Arts Magazine. Blissful Baking! Rose
12/9/2009 11:14 AM

Follow this thread by RSS
What is RSS?

Help

Need Help?

Take advantage of all the features the Message Boards has to offer including:
  • Formatting
  • Adding Photos
  • Inserting Link
  • And More!
Get Help Now
ENDECA_EXCLUDE_START

Don't miss a single recipe!




Email Address:

Recommendations

 
ENDECA_EXCLUDE_END
ENDECA_EXCLUDE_START
ENDECA_EXCLUDE_END