| Reviewed by: jnaluxton |
Date Posted: 10/11/2009 12:52:24 PM |
Rating:  |
Comments:
These are the exact cookies i used to love when I was a kid. Even while I was making the dough the smell took me back about thirty years. |
| Reviewed by: rn09 |
Date Posted: 10/3/2009 7:44:52 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
my neice made these and added a hershey's kiss in the middle.. they were great!! half the batch was gone within 5 minutes of cooling! this is a must try!! |
| Reviewed by: LuvMy2Kids |
Date Posted: 9/26/2009 5:07:40 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
This is the best peanut butter cookie recipe I have ever used! One batch is NEVER enough in my house as they are usually gone by the end of the night! |
| Reviewed by: Nicole in NH |
Date Posted: 6/21/2009 2:54:52 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
This is the only recipe I will use. Been making these for years, I have tried other, but the end result isn't as good. I always overfill the 1/2 c. peanut butter. This is the most consistently yummy cookie recipe! |
| Reviewed by: Mark-Sandy |
Date Posted: 6/11/2009 3:28:49 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
My mother would let me and my best friend make these very same cookies on rainy/snowy days when I was a kid (1960s). They are as good today as they were 45 years ago. My family scarf them down almost as fast as me. |
| Reviewed by: ShugaPlum |
Date Posted: 6/8/2009 9:34:06 PM |
Rating:  |
Comments:
I'm quite new to baking cookies, but the cookies turned out fine. They were good, but the ones my nanny made when I was a child taste a little better, I love peanut butter, maybe next time I'll just add a little more peanut butter. |
| Reviewed by: Mrs.Fritz |
Date Posted: 4/6/2009 11:37:07 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
I have my mother's Betty Crocker cookbook from 1961 and this is the same recipe that was published in that cookbook - to the letter! I grew up with these fantastic cookies and still make them today for my family.
That's 48 years without one single tweak...which just shows you that this recipe is tried and true. I believe that it's the combo of shortening and butter that makes these stand out against all the others. Trust me, this is the best old fashioned PB cookie out there. |
| Reviewed by: amethyst427 |
Date Posted: 10/13/2008 2:44:18 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
This is a great recipe. The taste and texture of the cookie is wonderful. Look no further. It's the best. |
| Reviewed by: Kimmi67 |
Date Posted: 10/8/2008 10:55:27 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
I lost my original Betty Crocker recipe for these cookies and have never found another recipe to compare...until now! I don't know if it has anything to do with the combination of butter and shortening? But these are by far my favorite pb cookie!! |
| Reviewed by: horsnrnd |
Date Posted: 9/14/2008 9:20:44 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
These were wonderful! I increased the peanut butter to 3/4c just b/c I love the pb taste. I actually had to hide these cookies from my husband b/c I made them for someone else and he kept eating them. GREAT RECIPE!!! |
| Reviewed by: natesmom94 |
Date Posted: 6/8/2008 4:13:02 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
This is my sceond time making these and they are the best peanut butter cookies ever. My whole family loved then. I also used Jiff peanut butter this time which I liked better. |
| Reviewed by: pblover |
Date Posted: 3/29/2008 10:56:21 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
These were fantastic! At first I was a little unsure because my dough seemed a little dry, but after baking they were YUMMY! The best ever! |
| Reviewed by: bakeit4me |
Date Posted: 3/11/2008 8:35:23 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
I use butter flavored crisco for the shortening and it's even better |
| Reviewed by: zackrude |
Date Posted: 2/1/2008 12:44:06 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
Tips: make in muffin tins for perfectly round cookies and they will still turn out amazing even if you do not refrigerate for the 2 hours :) %0d%0a%0d%0aZack and Monique |
| Reviewed by: jingjing101 |
Date Posted: 1/27/2008 7:59:38 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
i made this recipe for my 1 year anniversary...my boyfriend absolutely loved them [his room-mates too!]. |
| Reviewed by: Cooking Mary |
Date Posted: 1/22/2008 6:31:21 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
This recipe was "great". The peanut butter flavor was not to overpowering. Easy to make. I really like the texture of this cookie. Will definately make this my #1 cookie recipe. Thanks for the recipe. |
| Reviewed by: debrichde |
Date Posted: 1/21/2008 11:59:27 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
My family said these were the best peanut Butter Cookies and that this recipe was a keeper. |
| Reviewed by: Mona |
Date Posted: 1/18/2008 2:24:16 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
Simple, good peanut butter cookies. |
| Reviewed by: Steve Cookie |
Date Posted: 12/17/2007 12:15:19 AM |
Rating: |
Comments:
I like this basic recipe but I substitute more real butter for the shortening. The cookies disappear really, really fast so must be doing something right. |
| Reviewed by: missy from buffalo ny |
Date Posted: 12/13/2007 1:43:44 PM |
Rating: |
Comments:
These cookies are amazing! My boyfriend loves peanut butter so i added a little extra and he loved them.. the cookies were so yummy! very easy to make :) |
|