One thing that I want to point out is, looks and prestation. If you fixing it for just your family, it might not matter, but if your fixing it for others, the texture might matter. One of the reasons that I prefer canned pumpkin is because it is "so smooth"! If it is corse or grainy looking, it isn't as appealing,
. I always love my Mothers homemade pumpkin pie, made from libby's canned pumpkin and that recipe. Then my mother started making her own pumpkin, it was corse and grainy looking and often looked like it had already been eatten once,
, it took several years before it was smooth and I could bging myself to try it. Well, It was the same great pie!!!, I just couldn't get past the looks of it. No! I never told my Mother,wouldn't of hurt her feelings for anything!!! But I did ask questions about why it wasn't so smooth, she then learned to cook it longer, puree it untill smoother and NOT to use Jack'O'Lantern pumpkins or those that aren't pie pumpkins. Granna2 P.S. don't get rid of those seeds, rinse them, let them dry a little, then put a little oil, salt, & garlic on them and back them at 350 for 15-30 minutes, untill brown and crisp. Cool and eat, smaller ones, shells and all. There very good for you!! If you don't like garlic, use seasoning salt or just plain salt.